News | Business
13 Dec 2017 5:14
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Days of Xmas
  • News
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > Business

    MBIE investigates consultant payments leak

    The Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment has launched an investigation into a privacy breach over the leak of payments to thousands of consultants.

    8 December 2017

    The Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment has launched an investigation into a privacy breach over the leak of payments to thousands of consultants, the recruitment firms that supply them and contract details for the past four years.

    The data was anonymously emailed to BusinessDesk by an MBIE insider who claimed the ministry is about to "lie" about the true extent of its spending on consultants in answer to expenditure questions from a parliamentary select committee.

    The ministry denied it would mislead the select committee while confirming the data originated from its offices and was an internal document accessible to a very limited number of employees.

    The data show MBIE spent $82.9 million on contractors in 2016-17 and another tab on the spreadsheet shows $10.9m spent on consultants, listed by contract number.

    The total of the consultants and contractor tabs is $94m while MBIE's 2017 financial statements put operating expenditure on contractors at $40.6m and consulting services at $15.6m - a total of $56 million.

    The figures in the 2017 annual report "represent MBIE's fully reconciled and audited accounts as reported to parliament," a spokeswoman said.

    In addition to the spending on contractors and consultants in the 2016-17 year, "we obtain professional services from external suppliers with expenditure of $48.08m. This may include contractors where that is the appropriate means of service delivery."

    The ministry says the leaked data sheet was of raw numbers compiled for different purposes and couldn't be reconciled with the officially reported figures.

    The spreadsheet lists 2260 named contractors used by MBIE over the past four years and 1801 consulting firms and individuals listed by contract number.

    The top two contractors were paid more than $1 million each over the four years and 16 more received over $800,000.

    In seeking comment from MBIE, BusinessDesk agreed not to disclose or transmit any personal and commercially sensitive information.

    The ministry asked for the data to be deleted.

    "The information you received from an MBIE staff member alleges that MBIE is intending to mislead the select committee. This is not correct," Adrienne Meikle, deputy chief executive, corporate governance and information said.

    "We are fully responsible and accountable for our spending, and report on that spending through our annual report and the select committee process."

    MBIE was this year criticised by then Labour's economic development spokesman David Clark for its spending on external consultants and contractors for what he said was core business.

    The so-called super-ministry has also come in for previous criticism, including a reported $140,000 on a curved screen TV for its head office reception.

    The cover note on the email leak says the person doesn't view themselves as an 'Edward Snowden' character "but felt there just needed to be some transparency about what was happening with this reckless spending of taxpayer money."

    "I don't blame the current CFO or CE - the people responsible for signing so much of this spending are the slightly lower level DCE's and general managers," the person said.

    "This has been a difficult thing to do as I obviously work at this ministry and do not wish to lose my job there. It upsets me as a taxpayer to have to write this but in the end, there was little choice.

    "I could have raised concern within govt but I don't believe my concerns would have been properly acted upon."

    MBIE said staff who had issues of concern or felt put in a position of 'whistle-blower' could use the ministry's "independent, anonymous 24-hour integrity line".


    © 2017 NZN, NZCity

     Other Business News
     12 Dec: Kiwi up vs Aussie on weak biz confidence
     12 Dec: Councillors unhappy at Karori campus sale
     12 Dec: Napier Port profit hits record in 2017
     12 Dec: OG Oil & Gas hits 50pc NZOG threshold
     12 Dec: Govt to boost sustainable farming fund
     12 Dec: Kiwis take up ultra-fast net in droves
     11 Dec: Shares rise, led by Metro Glass, Heartland
     Top Stories

    Pulver 'delivered' for Australian rugby More...

    Kiwi up vs Aussie on weak biz confidence More...

     Today's News

    Donald Trump's Jerusalem move ends US role in peace process, Palestinian leader Hanan Ashrawi says 4:37

    PNG's life-saving church rural health services face closure after months without government funding 22:47

    Socceroos coach must be Aussie: Merrick 21:57

    Rugby League:
    RLPA calls for review of third party deals 21:17

    Chinese 'rooftopper' Wu Yongning plunges to his death from 62-storey tower as $20,000 stunt goes wrong 20:17

    Ruby Rose has "always wanted" children 20:16

    Law and Order:
    PNG deputy electoral commissioner Simon Sinai arrested and charged with corruption 19:57

    Injuries to test Glory's A-League depth 19:47

    Anastacia is "single with a smile" 19:46

    Ed Sheeran is planning a "lo-fi album" inspired by Bruce Springsteen 19:16

     News Search

    Power Search

    © 2017 New Zealand City Ltd