News | International
18 Oct 2017 11:25
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Olympic Games
  • Ski Report
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > International

    Buddhist faces 15 years in jail for questioning historical accuracy of royal elephant battle

    The story of a former Thai king slaying a Burmese prince in a duel while riding elephants is at the centre of a police investigation against an elderly Buddhist intellectual, who faces 15 years in jail for questioning the historical accuracy of the event.


    The story of a former Thai king slaying a Burmese prince in a duel while riding elephants is at the centre of a police investigation against an elderly Buddhist intellectual who faces 15 years jail for questioning the historical accuracy of the event.

    Sulak Sivaraksa, 85, made the comments at a university seminar in 2014 and was charged then, but the case has resurfaced, with police saying they have now finished their investigation.

    This week police escorted Mr Sulak to meet the prosecutor, who will decide whether to go ahead with the case.

    He is charged with lese majeste, which protects the king, queen, heir and regent from defamation, but has been more broadly applied to cover the king's dog, past kings and even Facebook "likes" of controversial material.

    Mr Sulak insists he has done nothing wrong.

    "My point is, if you want to learn history, you have to get all facts from the past as much as you can, and I just state the facts," he said.

    The case comes just before the cremation of Thailand's widely-revered King Bhumibol Adulyadej later this month, but Mr Sulak said he was not sure why the charges had been revived.

    "Well, I wish I knew," he said.

    "The country is run by dictatorship so [there's] no regard to the rule of law and for the army, King Naresuan is a great hero, you see, and the elephant combat is real for them."

    Mr Sulak is a renowned social critic and the founder of the International Network of Engaged Buddhists. He has been nominated twice for the Nobel Peace Prize. 

    His autobiography - Loyalty Demands Dissent - contains a foreword from the Dalai Lama.

    Although he describes himself as a royalist, he has been charged several times with lese majeste.

    Different versions of historic duel

    The story of the elephant duel has been the subject of many movies and television series in Thailand and is held dear by the military, which currently runs the country.

    "Duel on elephant back was supposed to be the height of warfare at that time," said Chris Baker, a Thai-speaking historian who has published history books and translations of poems.

    "It's a bit like knights used to joust ... so it's very romantic to have an elephant duel."

    According to the mainstream retelling, Thai King Naresuan challenged Burmese Crown Prince Mingyi Swa to a duel in 1593.

    The two fought from the backs of elephants and King Naresuan killed Prince Mingyi Swa with his lance, according to the movie version.

    Mr Baker recently published a book about this period of Thai history, so the source material is fresh in his mind.

    "There's around 10 different accounts of the incident and it's important to state at the beginning that not one of these claims to be an eyewitness account," he said.

    "So these are all just kind of stories about an event ... and these are all different, no two are the same and they differ about every single detail of the thing."

    Mr Baker said even the location of the elephant battle is disputed.

    "Then there's the question of whether ... it was a formal duel, whether Naresuan challenged the Burmese prince or in some accounts they just met in the middle of the battle and fought against one another.

    "More importantly there's a question, big differences in how he is killed. [In] the mainstream version, Naresuan kills him with a sword. In other versions the Burmese prince is killed with a bullet."

    Royal defamation for dead kings

    Besides the question of historical accuracy, there is the application of the lese majeste law, which protects the king, queen, heir and regent from slander, but is now being used to shield dead kings too.

    "We used to think it was pretty simply in that it identified who were the personages who could be insulted and therefore the law could be invoked," Mr Baker said.

    "But it now seems to be much broader than that and I think it's very difficult to understand now."

    On December 7, the prosecutor will announce whether to go ahead with the case against Mr Sulak.

    If it does go ahead, the trial would be held in a military court, possibly in secret.

    "So I'm at the mercy of the military tribunal... if they want to be fair, if they want to be sincere I'll get acquitted, but if they want to punish me, well, what can you do? There's no rule of law," Mr Sulak said.

    © 2017 ABC Australian Broadcasting Corporation. All rights reserved


     Other International News
     18 Oct: Royal baby: Duke and Duchess of Cambridge confirm third child expected in April
     18 Oct: Daphne Caruana Galizia: Car-bomb murder of Maltese journalist 'an attack on free press and democracy'
     18 Oct: Daphne Caruana Galizia: Who was the Maltese journalist murdered in a car bomb explosion?
     18 Oct: What is the #MeToo campaign?
     17 Oct: China's President Xi Jinping poised to take absolute power at Communist Party Congress
     17 Oct: Six people missing after fishing vessel capsizes north of Bundaberg
     17 Oct: Bowe Bergdahl: US soldier who spent five years in Taliban captivity pleads guilty to desertion
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    NZ brace for another Brisbane nailbiter More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    Mercury, Genesis increase generation More...



     Today's News

    Law and Order:
    Dairy scientist heads to prison for fraud 11:07

    Entertainment:
    Heidi Montag nearly had a panic attack when she left her son for the first time 11:03

    Sailing:
    Kiwi sailors set promising World Cup pace 10:47

    Entertainment:
    Calum Best's late father George left him in debt 10:33

    Business:
    Mercury, Genesis increase generation 10:27

    Hamilton:
    Royal baby: Duke and Duchess of Cambridge confirm third child expected in April 10:07

    Law and Order:
    Insurer sues over Port Hills fires 10:07

    Entertainment:
    Michael Fassbender and Alicia Vikander have tied the knot 10:03

    Entertainment:
    Ashley Graham's faith stops her going "crazy" 9:33

    Rugby League:
    Martin, Leuluai diplomatic on Taumalolo 9:27


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2017 New Zealand City Ltd