News | Politics
16 Jul 2018 11:20
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > Politics

    Brexit plan that could bring down the British Government is still only a starting point

    Two years after the Brexit referendum, Theresa May's cabinet agreed on the country's vision for its future relationship with the EU. But it has already led to a flurry of resignations, writes Nikos Skoutaris.


    Two years after the referendum, the UK Government briefly appeared to agree on its vision for the future UK-EU relationship — a three-page document, outlining the UK position, was published following a long meeting of cabinet ministers at the Prime Minister's country retreat of Chequers on July 6.

    The new position aims to address the Irish border issue and potentially offers a softer version of Brexit than was previously talked about. It has prompted the resignation of three ministers. Brexit secretary, David Davis, and his number two at the Department for Exiting the EU, Steve Baker, stepped down just 50 hours after the publication of the three-page document. This was followed by foreign secretary, Boris Johnson. Such dramatic developments raise serious questions for the UK's Brexit strategy and the future of the Government itself.

    So what was agreed to at Chequers and why has it led to these resignations? Mr Davis stepped down because he felt the new plan cedes too much control to the EU. Notwithstanding, the new plan should be understood as only the starting point of negotiations over the future UK-EU relationship. In that sense, we should expect the UK position to further evolve in the months to come.

    Previous proposals

    The Government's new position has substantially evolved from its previous proposals for the UK's future economic relationship with the EU. It has been dubbed a "third way" between the two proposals that the Government published in August 2017.

    The first was a highly streamlined customs arrangement that came to be known as "max-fac" (short for maximum facilitation). It aimed to simplify the UK's customs arrangement with the EU by using a variety of IT solutions to avoid a customs border between Northern Ireland and the Republic. Jon Thompson, head of HM Revenue and Customs estimated the cost of building the necessary infrastructure for this option would be about £20 billion.

    According to the second model, a new customs partnership, the UK would mirror "the EU's requirements for imports from the rest of the world" as if the UK was still a member of the EU's customs union. The UK, under this model, would still be free to pursue its independent trade policy.

    This could potentially lead to differences in its tariffs with the EU ones. To deal with this problem, an unprecedented and untested repayment mechanism was proposed. According to it, imports to the UK would pay whichever was the higher of the UK's or the EU's tariff rates and traders would claim "a refund for the difference between the two when the goods were sold to an end user in the country charging lower tariffs".

    Apart from the cost and the feasibility, the biggest problem of the previous two proposals was that neither of them addressed effectively the Irish border conundrum. Neither could secure a frictionless, invisible border, given the UK's intention is to leave the single market and the customs union after Brexit.

    The new proposal

    As the UK Government had previously conceded, upholding its Irish border commitments required regulatory alignment. Without the same regulatory standards on the two sides of the border, checks would be required on the various products that would be crossing it to ensure the integrity of the single market.

    This is why the new plan proposes to establish a free trade area for goods between the UK and the EU where "a common rulebook for all goods including agri-food" will exist. The UK will commit, by international agreement, "to ongoing harmonisation with EU rules on goods". This echoes the mechanism of the European Economic Area whose members have to adopt the new or reformed regulations that the EU institutions produce.

    At the same time, the Government contends that parliament can guard the UK legal order from future EU legislation in an arrangement that somehow resembles the EU's relationship with Switzerland. Given the ongoing crisis in EU-Switzerland relations over the issue of free movement of people, the UK Government is right to recognise that such action might lead to unforeseen consequences. At the same time, it effectively puts into question whether the UK Parliament would have real power to diverge from EU regulations on goods.

    The starting point of negotiations

    The latest proposal, which came out of Chequers is not the definitive end state of the future UK-EU relationship, as some have suggested.

    But even if the resignations of Britain's main negotiator and the foreign secretary do not lead to a political crisis, the Chequers deal should be understood as the UK starting position in its negotiations with the EU.

    The Chequers proposal does not sit comfortably with the models for the EU-UK relationship that the EU has already suggested. It is not a Canada-style free trade agreement with the Northern Ireland backstop option. Nor is it an economic relationship that allows the application of all four fundamental freedoms of movement, as the "Norway" option does.

    Still, it is the first comprehensive position that the UK has put forward. So the UK will be hoping that the EU will consider it.

    Even if the EU does not reject the UK position outright, the Government should expect that issues such as its contribution to the new EU budget and the role of the European Court of Justice are raised and seriously considered in the months to come. This is still only the beginning of the process that will hopefully lead to an orderly Brexit and mutually beneficial future with the EU.

    Nikos Skoutaris is a lecturer in European Union Law in the School of Law at the University of East Anglia.

    This article was first published on The Conversation.


    ABC




    © 2018 ABC Australian Broadcasting Corporation. All rights reserved


     Other Politics News
     15 Jul: The Productivity Commission will hold an inquiry into local government funding and financing
     14 Jul: Auckland households and businesses will get some extra pocket money in August or September thanks to Vector
     14 Jul: A concept plan for the re-entry into the Pike River mine has been presented to the victims' families
     14 Jul: There's more evidence the electric car revolution is gathering speed
     13 Jul: A 300-million-dollar redevelopment at Auckland Prison aims to provide better rehabilitation and mental health treatment for our most volatile and dangerous prisoners
     13 Jul: Wellington bus users are being told to prepare for the biggest changes ever made to the network
     13 Jul: But the Conservation Minister says there's nothing she can do
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    The All Blacks have kept hold of a couple of promising young players for next year's Rugby World Cup More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    Auckland households and businesses will get some extra pocket money in August or September thanks to Vector More...



     Today's News

    International:
    World Cup final: When is it, how to watch and who's playing 10:47

    Tennis:
    Wimbledon: Novak Djokovic beats Kevin Anderson in straight sets to win fourth title 10:47

    Law and Order:
    Police are treating the death of a man at Bay of Plenty's McLaren Falls as suspicious 10:47

    International:
    World Cup: France beats Croatia 4-2 to become world champion for a second time 10:17

    Rugby:
    The All Blacks have kept hold of a couple of promising young players for next year's Rugby World Cup 10:17

    Law and Order:
    Didier Deschamps has become the third man to lift the football World Cup as a player and a manager 6:27

    Soccer:
    World Cup: Can winning the final heal France's divisions? 4:37

    Motoring:
    A truck driver's had a lucky escape in Waikato after his vehicle careened off the road into floodwaters 20:47

    Rugby League:
    The Warriors have returned to winning ways in the NRL with a 26-6 thrashing of the Broncos in Brisbane 18:37

    Rugby League:
    The Warriors have snapped a two game NRL losing run with a commanding 26-6 win over the Broncos in Brisbane 18:07


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2018 New Zealand City Ltd