News | International
19 Jul 2019 10:14
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > International

    Sir Kim Darroch's cable leaks about Donald Trump's White House: Who or what was behind it?

    The leaking of Sir Kim Darroch's confidential memos labelling the Trump White House "inept" and "incompetent" saw the highly-experienced ambassador lose his job and strained US-UK diplomatic relations.

    The leaking of Sir Kim Darroch's confidential memos labelling the Trump White House "inept" and "incompetent" saw the highly experienced United Kingdom ambassador to the United States lose his job, as US-UK diplomatic relations reach a low point.

    But the fallout could be more wide-ranging, with police asked to join the investigation into who gave the documents to UK newspaper the Mail on Sunday.

    Political tensions in the UK are already at breaking point as the country navigates Brexit and seeks a new Prime Minister to replace Theresa May.

    While all sides were quick to condemn the leak, the search for who may be responsible for it and their political leanings and motivations will put everyone under scrutiny.

    On Tuesday Conservative MP Tom Tugendhat, chair of the foreign affairs committee, told the Commons he had sent a letter to the Metropolitan Police requesting it to open a criminal investigation.

    The Cabinet Office is leading the cross-government investigation into the leak, and on Thursday Downing Street confirmed "initial discussions" have been held with police over the probe.

    While many have their suspicions, in some circles the finger-pointing has already begun.

    What was leaked and who leaked it?

    Emails and diplomatic telegrams (DipTels) going back to 2017 were given to the Mail on Sunday.

    DipTels are encoded before they are sent and decoded when they get to the Foreign Office in London, retired British diplomat Sir Ivor Roberts told the ABC.

    Sir Ivor was the UK's ambassador to Yugoslavia during the Bosnian conflict and later served as Britain's ambassador to Italy and Ireland.

    "An ambassador sends an assessment, a report, an analysis of what's going on in their home country as long as they think it'll be useful to be read," he said.

    "When I was ambassador to Yugoslavia during the Bosnian war it was on a daily basis — there was so much happening and so much interest back in London as to what was happening.

    "And that will be the view also in Washington, I think the ambassador there will be providing very regular updates."

    He believes those with access to Sir Kim's memos would be limited.

    "The distribution can vary between a very narrow distribution, it depends on what you put on your telegram," he said.

    "You can say 'personal for' and then list a handful of people, or you can just put it to the general distribution and say address it to the Foreign Office generally and it will have a very big distribution, maybe hundreds."

    But the fact that the leaked memos span a nearly three-year period will narrow down the field of suspects.

    "If it was one document it would be virtually impossible, but the same person dealing with the same subject who'd have access to all of these will be relatively small," Sir Ivor said.

    Bronwen Maddox, director of the Institute For Government, agreed with Sir Ivor's assessment that the timeframe will aid the search for the responsible party.

    "It seems as if there's two different sorts of cables — ones that would have had quite a wide circulation, but others that are very recent, in the past few weeks, that would only have had a circulation of five to 10 people," she told the ABC.

    "So I think the mood for the officials looking at this is that because some of them were very recent, they're tipping away from thinking it's a former disgruntled official and more like someone with current access."

    Was Sir Kim's Brexit stance a motivation?

    There is speculation Sir Kim Darroch's ties with Brussels and the European Union led to the leaking of his memos and ultimately his downfall as ambassador.

    Prior to his role as the US ambassador he was Britain's permanent representative to the EU, and some Conservative politicians believed his pro-Europe stance hindered his performance as a civil servant.

    "Kim's entire career has been entirely devoted to the EU," Brexit-backing Tory MP Bill Cash told Sky News.

    "He has an unbelievably strong commitment to us staying in the EU and that is worrying.

    "Many figures in the civil service have had a very tough problem in promoting British interests because they are so embedded in the idea that we should be in the EU."

    Brexiteer and former foreign secretary Boris Johnson is the frontrunner to replace Theresa May as leader of the Conservative Party in just under two weeks, and some say clearing Sir Kim from his role will allow an ambassador with a pro-Brexit stance to be installed in Washington.

    Nigel Farage, leader of the Brexit Party and a man Mr Trump suggested would do a "great job" as ambassador to the US, was quick to jump on the leak to the Mail on Sunday and said Sir Kim was "totally unsuitable for the job".

    The Mail on Sunday journalist who received the leaks, Isabel Oakeshott, has close ties to Mr Farage and other prominent Brexiteers, even penning a book about them.

    But she was quick to hose down the supposed plot against Sir Kim.

    "Like I've said, sometimes a great story is just that; not some kind of global conspiracy," she tweeted.

    But Sir Ivor Roberts believes the Brexit narrative is not far from the truth.

    "If anyone asked me to speculate I would say I would have thought it would be a Brexiteer minister in another government department who is operating on the basis that Kim Darroch is part of the Foreign Office, the diplomats of whom are still unreconciled to Brexit and are really unreconstructed Remainers, and not particularly sympathetic to Donald Trump," he said.

    Bronwen Maddox said finding the culprit is vital.

    "It all matters, because this type of government has to happen confidentially," she said.

    "MPs obviously are partisan but we still think that they are prepared to respect convention, and what you've seen in Brexit is people caring so much about their version of the future that they sort of butt through convention.

    "I hope this isn't an example of it, but it feels like it.'

    © 2019 ABC Australian Broadcasting Corporation. All rights reserved

     Other International News
     19 Jul: China's treatment of Uyghurs called 'stain of the century' by US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo
     19 Jul: As the Moon landing unfolded, Buzz Aldrin took communion. Here's why
     19 Jul: Netball World Cup lacking a competitive pulse after a week of lopsided lead-up games
     19 Jul: Australia beats New Zealand 50-49 at Netball World Cup in England
     18 Jul: Flight 73 pilots ignored alerts in fatal Air Niugini crash, report finds
     18 Jul: Storm Area 51 is a Facebook joke. There are lots of reasons it's a bad idea
     18 Jul: Google bans controversial ticket reseller Viagogo from top search results
     Top Stories

    Beauden Barrett is keen to just play rugby after a busy time off the field More...

    Air passengers travelling from Invercargill will soon face screening lanes and x-ray machines More...

     Today's News

    Billy Porter feels "really blessed" after becoming the first openly gay black man to receive an Emmy nomination for Outstanding Lead Actor 10:09

    China's treatment of Uyghurs called 'stain of the century' by US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo 10:07

    Accident and Emergency:
    A man's in a critical condition after being pulled from the water in the Far North 10:07

    Jared Harris says his 'Chernobyl' Emmy nomination is "pretty amazing" 9:39

    As the Moon landing unfolded, Buzz Aldrin took communion. Here's why 9:17

    R. Kelly has pled not guilty to 13 alleged sex trafficking charges 9:09

    It's New Zealand versus England for a spot in the Netball World Cup final in Liverpool 8:57

    Mandy Moore says it's "pretty bonkers" that she has received her first Emmy nomination 8:39

    Duane 'Dog' Chapman won't remarry following Beth Chapman's death 8:09

    Beauden Barrett is keen to just play rugby after a busy time off the field 8:07

     News Search

    Power Search

    © 2019 New Zealand City Ltd