News | International
28 Feb 2020 14:32
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > International

    How the coronavirus emergency is exploited on eBay and Amazon

    Bogus books. Dodgy face masks. 'I survived the coronavirus' t-shirts. Online retailers are exploiting the health crisis.

    The novel coronavirus outbreak has shut down cities and closed borders, but online, there is no limit to how the crisis can be exploited for clicks and cash.

    Retailers are selling an abundance of face masks on eBay — many with dubious health claims — tagged with "coronavirus" to push them to the top of search rankings.

    The company said it has begun removing listings that make misleading assertions after being contacted by ABC Science.

    Meanwhile, searching for "coronavirus" on Amazon offers a book promising to guide readers through the outbreak, now officially named COVID-19.

    The author, who does not claim to have medical qualifications, is also selling unauthorised biographies of Riverdale actor Cole Sprouse and presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg.

    And on Google's shopping page, you can find a "stop the coronavirus" t-shirt for around AUD$26.

    Online marketplaces have long been reactive to a public crisis, and can often feel largely lawless. Their appeal is that almost anyone can become a retailer, but the danger is anyone can.

    That's how you end up with a prominent eBay listing for 50 Russian-made facemasks that will protect "against coronovirus [sic], flu and other airborne diseases". (Reader, they cannot).

    The 'infodemic'

    For those not on the frontline of the outbreak, the novel coronavirus has largely been experienced online.

    On social media, messages from health authorities may sit right next to conspiracy theories.

    The World Health Organisation calls it an "infodemic". There is too much information, it argues, which "makes it hard for people to find trustworthy sources and reliable guidance when they need it".

    Online marketplaces are a particular challenge: on the street, we know a pharmacy is more likely to be a reliable source of health advice than a corner store. But on the internet, those shopfronts are presented as indistinguishable search results.

    "All sorts of claims are mixed up together," said Professor Jeannie Paterson, a consumer law specialist at Melbourne University Law School.

    "The ones that come up first aren't the most truthful claims, but often the ones that have paid the most in the bidding war for prominence."

    A quick glance at Amazon's top results for "coronavirus" this week, for the most part, are not promising.

    Some of the ebooks for sale appear to repurpose general information about flu-like diseases — information that is available for free on government health websites. But others take a more troubling turn.

    One ebook, which the ABC has chosen not to name, discusses the possibility the novel coronavirus was caused by biohazard research that escaped the lab — a conspiracy theory not substantiated by any public health authority.

    It also claims there is evidence to suggest the virus is engineered and potentially operates similarly to HIV. Amazon declined to comment.

    Who is responsible?

    eBay says it has updated its filters to block new listings "marketed to treat or cure coronavirus".

    Yet if someone advertises a product in a misleading way — claiming it will protect you from the disease when it won't, for example — it could be misleading conduct and Australian regulators can take action.

    The Therapeutic Goods Administration recently warned penalties could apply to erroneous claims about products that promise to prevent or treat the virus.

    The platform or marketplace advertising the product is typically not responsible, however, but the law is not yet settled.

    According to Professor Paterson, the platform could be liable if it endorses the product or claim in some way.

    "The platforms may be more liable than they realise, and that's yet to be tested," she said.

    "I would say they have an ethical responsibility to draw the line."

    'Uncanny ecommerce'

    Beyond misinformation and bogus health claims, the burgeoning industry of coronavirus merchandise strays into what writer Jenny Odell calls "uncanny ecommerce".

    High up on my Google's shopping listings for "coronavirus" this week were t-shirts sold on the website Spreadshirt.

    This marketplace allows retailers to submit designs, which can then be printed for anyone who wants to purchase.

    One seller, who the website says is based in Turkey, will sell you a coronavirus mason jar — with a decal that says "#coronavirus" over an image of a world map wearing a Chinese flag face mask.

    And instead of five golden stars, the flag shows five yellow viruses.

    Eike Adler, Spreadshirt's press officer, said the company believes the free and open exchange of ideas on products is key to self-expression.

    Designs can be rejected if they contain illegal content, hate speech, pornography or glorified violence, but generally almost anything goes.

    "Spreadshirt prints almost all submitted designs whether we as a company or individuals like them or not," he said.

    Of course, a distasteful mason jar does not present the same risk as a badly marketed face mask. But in search results, they're likely to be displayed as one and the same.

    "Digital platforms have become all consuming, and they've become a source of knowledge," Professor Paterson said.

    "We as consumers are less able to sort truthful claims from untruthful claims."

    © 2020 ABC Australian Broadcasting Corporation. All rights reserved

     Other International News
     28 Feb: Amazon's new show Hunters has Al Pacino leading a squad of Nazi-fighting vigilantes — but how accurate is it?
     28 Feb: Olympic champion Mo Farah faces renewed doping suspicions following British TV investigation
     28 Feb: A 'mini-moon' has been orbiting the Earth for three years — but astronomers say it will not be around forever
     28 Feb: How your brain disentangles words and melody from a single line of song
     28 Feb: A man has been arrested after Manchester City manager Pep Guardiola's emails were allegedly hacked
     27 Feb: China's Chang'e-4 provides first detailed images of what lies beneath the far side of the Moon
     27 Feb: Our stiff feet have evolved for walking and running, and a large part of that could be thanks to our transverse arch
     Top Stories

    The Crusaders will avoid a trip to Tokyo this Super Rugby season with SANZAAR announcing changes to the draw to allay coronavirus fears in Tokyo More...

    Port of Tauranga has reduced its full-year profit guidance as coronavirus continues to cause trade uncertainty More...

     Today's News

    JoJo felt "free" after being released by her record label 14:29

    Law and Order:
    A year on from a triple fatality at Matata, WorkSafe has laid charges against Higgins Construction 14:07

    Eva Mendes wants to play a Disney villain 13:59

    Veteran Kiwi David Smail has put himself in a position to contend at the New Zealand Open 13:47

    Bebe Rexha doesn't want to be defined by her bipolar disorder diagnosis 13:29

    Law and Order:
    A guilty plea to a murder 24-years ago - has drawn gasps from friends and family of Christchurch woman Angela Blackmoore 13:27

    Law and Order:
    Twenty four years later ... a man has pleaded guilty to beating a young Christchurch mum to death 13:17

    Jacinda Ardern's due to try make moves on Australia's forced deportation of New Zealanders 13:17

    The Crusaders will avoid a trip to Tokyo this Super Rugby season with SANZAAR announcing changes to the draw to allay coronavirus fears in Tokyo 13:07

    Mark Wahlberg's 10-year-old daughter is easily embarrassed by her movie star dad 12:59

     News Search

    Power Search

    © 2020 New Zealand City Ltd