News | International
28 Oct 2020 15:45
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > International

    Coronavirus takes a back seat ahead of New Caledonia's second independence referendum

    Increasingly aggressive campaigns for and against New Caledonia's French rule have pushed the coronavirus pandemic out of voters' minds as the Pacific nation stages another independence referendum.

    As coronavirus cases escalate in France, in the tiny French territory of New Caledonia, the pandemic has taken a back seat to concerns around its upcoming referendum on independence.

    This Sunday, more than 180,000 voters will cast their ballot to find out whether New Caledonia will stick with France or become its own independent state.

    They will be asked to vote Yes or No to the question: "Do you want New Caledonia to accede to full sovereignty and become independent?"

    It's the second time in two years that New Caledonia will hold an independence referendum—back in 2018, the territory narrowly decided to stay with France.

    But an aggressive 2020 campaign fought by both the pro-independence and pro-French blocs has left some fearing further disharmony, no matter which side wins this weekend.

    'A question of dignity'

    Many of New Caledonia's Indigenous Kanak voters see Sunday's vote as a referendum on their right to govern their land.

    "It is really a question of dignity," said Patricia Goa, a pro-independence campaigner and politician in New Caledonia's congress.

    "It's really important for us Kanaks and for Caledonians to decide for ourselves. That's where the fight is now."

    Thirty years ago, after a bloody civil conflict referred to as "the Events", the French state, pro-independence Kanak leaders and French loyalists signed a peace deal to end the violence.

    It eventually led to the 1998 Noumea Accord that has charted a transfer of some governance powers from France to New Caledonia.

    That Accord says New Caledonia can have, at most, three referenda on its independence from France.

    But the results of the first vote in 2018 revealed rigid ethnic and geographic divides had coloured the vote.

    Many New Caledonians with a European background favoured remaining with Paris, while Kanak voters were more likely to vote for independence.

    That suggests to New Caledonian political researcher Pierre-Christophe Pantz that many voters will not change their minds come Sunday's second referendum.

    "We've had these social, ethnic and geographic divisions in the distribution of votes for 30 years, and I really can't imagine a radical change between the second and first referendum," Dr Pantz said.

    Wider geo-political concerns shadow Sunday's vote

    French President Emanuel Macron has signalled a desire to counter China's rise in the Indo-pacific region, through new alliances with Australia and Japan.

    Anti-independence politician Phillipe Gomes, who represents New Caledonia in France's national assembly, said if New Caledonia becomes independent, it could open the door to greater Chinese influence.

    "An independent New Caledonia is a New Caledonia without a defence, in the hands of China," he said.

    However, not everyone agrees — public law professor Mathias Chauchat said pro-independence leaders are keen to form closer ties with Australia and New Zealand, if the Yes vote is successful.

    "Nobody will accept China as a political partner," he said.

    "[The pro-independence group] FLNKS wants a partnership with France as a first option. The second one is to invite Australia and New Zealand to come and help the country."

    Fears of growing hostility between blocs

    Though Dr Pantz expects not much will change on Sunday, he said the lead up to the referendum has been more cut-throat this year than ever before.

    He points to two incidents that for him reveal a growing tension around this question of New Caledonian independence.

    "A banner in the French colours, blue, white and red, was set alight — it was a symbol of France set on fire," Dr Pantz said.

    "And then the grand traditional hut in the Customary Senate was also burnt down … the investigations revealed that these were isolated events, not linked to the independence or loyalist movements.

    "But they do show us that the climate here is a bit toxic."

    Voters have also felt that this year's referendum is shaping up to be more combative.

    "It's really very unpleasant," said Delphine, a voter from Noumea, New Caledonia's capital.

    "I have seen that people are taking much more radical positions than they did in 2018."

    Despite voting Yes to independence during the first referendum, Delphine, who declined to give her surname as she feared backlash over her past vote, said she wasn't sure about her decision at the ballot box on Sunday.

    She said the referendum forced people like her to choose their loyalty to either France or New Caledonia, but her identity was much more complex than that.

    "I find that the question that we're asking here, Yes or No, isn't really satisfying."

    A vote shielded from coronavirus concerns

    New Caledonia is considered "COVID-Free" by officials, with no active cases of the virus and no reports of community transmission.

    Just 27 cases have been recorded in the territory so far, all of them related to travellers.

    But the pandemic has featured in the campaigns for both the Yes and No vote.

    "The pro-independence bloc and anti-independence bloc have both tried to take advantage of the pandemic," Dr Pantz said.

    "We see the pro-independence groups asking for French state officials to return to France because of their handling of the crisis, and the non-independence groups saying that the reason we were able to handle the crisis was because of France's support."

    Back in May, pro-independence leader Daniel Goa accused France of meddling in New Caledonia's affairs in its handling of the pandemic and said authorities had put Kanak lives at risk by allowing French officials into the country.

    France's High Commission responded by saying that France had taken "necessary measures" to protect "every Caledonian without any distinction between them".

    But today, anti-independence politician Phillip Gomes said the pandemic was not a major concern for voters in the referendum.

    "New Caledonia is in a bubble, and we don't have any restrictions, no social distancing. We live like before, nothing's changed," he said.

    © 2020 ABC Australian Broadcasting Corporation. All rights reserved

     Other International News
     28 Oct: Consumer prices surge 1.6 per cent over September quarter as free childcare policy ends
     28 Oct: Five quick questions answered about finding water on the Moon
     28 Oct: When will we know the results of the 2020 US election? It could get complicated
     28 Oct: UK records highest daily COVID-19 death toll since May, study shows declining antibody immunity
     28 Oct: Deb Frecklington says Queensland had four consecutive years of the highest unemployment in the nation before the pandemic. Is that correct?
     28 Oct: How to prepare yourself — and your brain — to face bushfires
     27 Oct: 'Detached' reef bigger than Empire State building discovered in 500 metres of water off Queensland
     Top Stories

    The Barbarians who broke coronavirus protocols ahead of their scheduled rugby match with England, will not face a police investigation More...

    A penalty for overcharging customers at one of Auckland's biggest supermarkets, Pak'nSave Mangere More...

     Today's News

    Fraser Sheat has ripped through the Wellington batting line-up to give Canterbury the advantage on day one of the second round of the Plunket Shield 15:27

    Lily James "threw a tantrum" on a movie set over the Spice Girls 15:25

    The Silver Ferns are looking to improve their work off the ball in tonight's first netball test against England in Hamilton 14:57

    Anthony Mackie "cared deeply" about Chadwick Boseman 14:55

    Consumer prices surge 1.6 per cent over September quarter as free childcare policy ends 14:37

    Jennifer Lopez found it hard to be treated as an equal in the film industry 14:25

    Netball New Zealand's setting the standard for Covid-19 recovery, with the first post-pandemic international test match tonight 14:07

    Wickets galore in the opening session of the second round of cricket's Plunket Shield 14:07

    Khloe Kardashian is “hopeful about [her] future” with Tristan Thompson 13:55

    A penalty for overcharging customers at one of Auckland's biggest supermarkets, Pak'nSave Mangere 13:47

     News Search

    Power Search

    © 2020 New Zealand City Ltd