News | Business
19 Jul 2025 11:48
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > Business

    Seekers of Property Gains Beware

    A house sale in Wanaka was in the news recently. The owners bought it in 1968 for $7,500 and sold it for $820,000.


    That's a pretty nice capital gain. But:

    • It's not as amazing as it seems.

    It works out an annual rate of 14.4 per cent, which is high but not astounding.

    • It could give readers false hopes.

    Such gains are unlikely to be repeated. In the first 20 years that the couple owned the house, inflation averaged 11.6 per cent a year.

    In the last 15, it was only 2.5 per cent. And inflation seems highly unlikely to revert to the levels of the 70s and 80s.

    Just as importantly, this has been singled out as a remarkable gain. Such stories grab the headlines. But let me tell you about two house sales that didn't make the news.

    In the first case, the couple paid close to a million dollars for a beautiful old villa, close to downtown Auckland. Then the zone for Auckland Grammar School changed. The house was no longer within zone. Its value dropped by about $300,000.

    Another couple felt rather smug when the share market crashed in October 1987. They had recently sold all their shares to buy a $385,000 house in a blue chip suburb. A year later, they decided to move across town.

    House prices had fallen - probably largely because people were moving to smaller homes to repay share-related debts. But that was okay. The couple were buying and selling in the same market.

    They bought a new place, and put their old house on the market. Months later, they reluctantly accepted $270,000 - 30 per cent less than they paid for it. House values in the blue chip suburb had dropped much more than elsewhere in the city.

    Admittedly both these price falls were over short periods. No doubt the houses would have regained lost ground over time.

    But it can take several years. And even then, the loss would drag down long-term gains.

    At a time like this, when more and more people are speculating in property, it pays to remember that sayings like: "You can't go wrong with bricks and mortar" aren't always correct.

    At the risk of over-exposing BNZ economist Tony Alexander, who I quoted in my last column, I'm going to quote him again.

    He wrote recently of three groups:

    • Those driven by fear of missing out on rental property gains. They buy "without giving adequate thought to how realistic the purchase price is, or how great the demand from tenants at the rent needed to cover costs."

    They are inexperienced and "will be the least able to weather a downturn if one comes along."

    • Those driven by greed, who have already done well in property "but will now be looking to gear up into extra properties." They are starting to think about early retirement, "and will be unbearable at parties."

    • Those who have held rental property through several ups and downs. Most won't gear too much. "Their experience will help them avoid the greatest risks of this cycle."

    They will focus on getting rid of properties that have proved difficult to rent. The properties may need maintenance, or their suburb has deteriorated, says Alexander.

    And here's the crunch: This third group will be "getting rid of the rubbish to the above two groups."

    Alexander is not saying house prices are about to drop. He still thinks "this cycle has further to run." But price rises aren't likely to continue at the pace of the recent past.

    To those thinking of buying now: proceed with caution.

    © 2025 Mary Holm, NZCity

     Other Business News
     19 Jul: ???1;Restaurants and bars are under increasing pressure from rising wage bills
     18 Jul: Three people have been arrested in Christchurch, tracked by police using a commercial helicopter
     18 Jul: Meta investors settle $8b lawsuit with Zuckerberg over Facebook privacy
     18 Jul: Warnings the wild weather that's battered the top of the South Island - will push up produce prices
     18 Jul: A BNZ whistleblower's vowing to fight on, after being awarded more than 500-thousand dollars
     18 Jul: Culture changes in the east are causing price rises in the west
     18 Jul: Concerns the Commerce Commission's stripping millions from payment system innovation
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    Wellington hospitality venues are prepare for another big sporting weekend More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    ???1;Restaurants and bars are under increasing pressure from rising wage bills More...



     Today's News

    Golf:
    Golfer Matt Fitzpatrick insists the pressure lies with world number one Scottie Scheffler at the halfway mark of The Open major at Royal Portrush 11:47

    Motoring:
    Two people are seriously injured after a fleeing driver drove the wrong way on an Auckland motorway 11:37

    Politics:
    South Korea's new president faces battle over gender equality 11:37

    Politics:
    Foreign Minister Winston Peters is joining the international condemnation of malicious cyber activity by the Russian government 11:27

    Law and Order:
    The injunction's been lifted on the details behind allegations against former Police Deputy Commissioner Jevon McSkimming 11:27

    Entertainment:
    Jelly Roll sent Logan Paul crashing through a table during a chaotic episode of Jimmy Kimmel Live! 11:21

    International:
    Victoria's children's commissioner concedes 'no-one' overseeing key decisions of office, Joshua Brown red flag 11:17

    Entertainment:
    Rob Kardashian quit the family's reality TV projects because he wanted to put his "peace and happiness" first 10:51

    Health & Safety:
    Wellington hospitality venues are prepare for another big sporting weekend 10:47

    Politics:
    Druze community, divided between Syria and Israel, has fleeting connection during conflict 10:27


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2025 New Zealand City Ltd