News | International
21 Jul 2019 9:53
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > International

    Encryption laws developed after little consultation with Australian tech companies, FOI documents reveal

    Peter Dutton's encryption laws were "rushed" through Parliament, but government records released under freedom of information laws suggest the local tech sector was largely not at the table.


    Documents released by the Home Affairs department suggest it did not consult with Australian technology companies about its encryption laws before releasing a public draft.

    Government officials spoke multiple times with US technology giants Apple, Facebook and Microsoft about the proposed legislation in 2017 and 2018, according to heavily redacted records obtained under freedom of information laws.

    Telecommunication providers such as Telstra, Optus, Vodafone and Vocus are also named.

    But no brands from Australia's IT sector appear among the dozens of pages released so far, further fuelling industry complaints that the impact of the laws on local industry was not adequately considered as the bill was developed.

    Among other things, the laws give authorities power to compel a company to create a new technical way to access encrypted communications — a text message sent in the WhatsApp messaging service, for example.

    During a committee inquiry into the legislation in November 2018, Francis Galbally, chairman of Australian encryption provider Senetas, suggested companies like his own would be unable to prove to customers they had not made a product modification to help a government agency.

    "The bill, should it become law, will profoundly undermine the reputations of Australian software developers and hardware manufacturers in international markets," he said at the time.

    This concern is still largely shared by Alex McCauley, chief executive of the national start-ups advocacy group StartupAus, who said his industry should have been involved in the early consultation process.

    "[The information in the consultation documents is] not a list of companies that includes any Australian tech businesses, which is obviously problematic," he said.

    "[The laws make] it really difficult for Australian companies selling overseas to say with confidence that they have a secure system."

    Tech giants and telcos

    The confidential consultation documents indicate officials were in touch with Apple, Google, Facebook and Microsoft multiple times in 2017.

    Some of the companies appear to have been approached again in the weeks before a public exposure draft of the legislation was published in mid-August 2018, according to emails and calendar bookings.

    An undated "attendee snapshot"included in the documents lists Optus, Telstra, Vodafone, TPG, Vocus and the Communications Alliance.

    Department representatives also spoke with the Australian Strategic Policy Institute in 2017.

    Ron Gauci, chief executive of the Australian Information Industry Association, said it was "disappointing" his organisation was not consulted.

    "Had we been involved in the process in the first place ... hopefully we would have avoided some of the matters that still remain as issues for us," he explained.

    "Our major issue has always been the impact this legislation may have on those Australian organisations, particularly the smaller ones, and their competitiveness on a global scale."

    A Home Affairs spokesperson said the department consulted about the laws with a range of telecommunications, social media and technology companies operating within Australia — a process that is ongoing.

    The draft legislation was released to a number of companies for comment at a Ministerial roundtable in June 2018.

    "The laws do not create a standing obligation or compliance burden for the Australian technology sector," the spokesperson said.

    An array of law enforcement and public service officials were sometimes present at the meetings, the documents indicate, including representatives of the Attorney General's department, the Australian Federal Police, ASIO and the Communications department.

    'Substandard' consultation process

    Even some groups that were consulted prior to the release of the draft legislation did not find the process adequate.

    John Stanton, chief executive of the Communications Alliance, which represents the telecommunications sector, said "the basic message" was not to worry as the legislation "would not create any backdoors", when he met with government officials in 2017.

    "We would have preferred very much to sit down and engage with government on the detail," he added.

    Sunita Bose, managing director of the Digital Industry Group, whichrepresents Twitter, Google, Facebook and Microsoft, said the broader consultation process was appreciated albeit perceived as speedy.

    "We did raise concerns at the time that the Bill appeared to be fast-tracked through Parliament, ignoring the voices of a wide range of organisations who directly raised concerns," she said.

    Draft legislation was released for public consultation by Home Affairs in mid-August 2018, and was introduced in Parliament weeks later.

    The Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security's review of the bill was cut short after Home Affairs Minister Peter Dutton said authorities needed the additional powers before the Christmas break.

    The Assistance and Access Act then passed on Parliament's last sitting day in December 2018, as the Labor Party voted for the bill despite voicing numerous concerns, including inadequate judicial oversight.

    Digital Rights Watch (DRW) board member Lizzie O'Shea pointed out that many civil society groups were also excluded from the initial consultation process.

    "I've seen this happen time and again ... whereby there's a very significant piece of legislation or law reform that relates to technology, and the consultation process is substandard," she suggested. DRW wants the law repealed.

    The Communications Alliance's Mr Stanton said he hoped the government would work more closely with industry on future technology legislation.

    "Industries are not opposed to national security objectives, only to the mechanisms by which they seek to achieve them, if those are damaging to industry or the public," he said.

    The Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security is currently reviewing the laws, and is due to report in April 2020.

    Just before deadline, the Department of Home Affairs advised that two to five pages pertaining to the ABC's FOI request were missing and still being processed. Their content is unclear.


    ABC




    © 2019 ABC Australian Broadcasting Corporation. All rights reserved


     Other International News
     21 Jul: German prince fights for land seized by Nazis after his grandfather plotted to assassinate Hitler
     21 Jul: Climate change could drown Kiribati, but the nation looks for Noah's Ark
     21 Jul: A victim of the Christchurch gas explosion is fighting for his life as expert investigators probe what happened
     20 Jul: US retail giant denies factory in Xinjiang makes their clothes despite video, satellite evidence
     20 Jul: Man climbs down apartment block to escape fire Spider-Man-style in West Philadelphia
     20 Jul: Moon landing: Do you have the right stuff to land this quiz?
     20 Jul: Could art forgers be targeting Australia's biggest contemporary artist?
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    The Silver Ferns have showed tremendous poise and perseverance to topple England 47-45 in their netball World Cup semi-final in Liverpool More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    Silver Ferns captain Laura Langman is looking forward to going up against one of the best in the business in the netball World Cup semi-finals More...



     Today's News

    Living & Travel:
    British Airways has grounded all its flights to Cairo for at least a week, because of security concerns 9:36

    Basketball:
    Hawke's Bay have overcome a late surge from the Canterbury to book their spot in the National Basketball League final 9:36

    Rugby League:
    The Rabbitohs have scored three tries in the final 10 minutes to sink the Cowboys 30-18 in their NRL match in Townsville 8:46

    International:
    German prince fights for land seized by Nazis after his grandfather plotted to assassinate Hitler 8:46

    Rugby:
    The Silver Ferns have showed tremendous poise and perseverance to topple England 47-45 in their netball World Cup semi-final in Liverpool 8:36

    Environment:
    Climate change could drown Kiribati, but the nation looks for Noah's Ark 8:06

    Environment:
    Investigators are looking into a suspicious fire in Whanganui that's left two people with serious injuries 7:56

    Law and Order:
    Police have arrested a fourth person over an alleged 100 million dollar money-laundering syndicate operating in Sydney 7:46

    Law and Order:
    A victim of the Christchurch gas explosion is fighting for his life as expert investigators probe what happened 7:36

    Politics:
    Australia's policies on the deportation of Kiwis is detrimental to their health and rehabilitative needs 7:26


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2019 New Zealand City Ltd