News | Swimming
12 Dec 2019 8:58
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Days of Xmas
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > Sports > Swimming

    Translation difficulties mar Sun Yang's drug test appeal testimony

    Accused Chinese swimmer Sun Yang says drug testers failed to provide their ID as translation difficulties hinder hearing.

    To the Chinese Sun Yang is a hero — the first man to win Olympic Gold in the pool for their nation.

    But in Australia he's been marked a pariah, a swimming villain who will struggle to shake drug-cheat allegations, regardless of whether he's found not guilty by sport's highest judicial body.

    Australia's Mack Horton has made no secret of his dislike for his athletic rival, labelling the 27-year-old a "drug cheat" and refusing to stand on a medal podium with him in South Korea earlier this year at the swimming world championships.

    Sun Yang, all six feet and seven inches of him, dominated the room as the Court of Arbitration for Sport began its proceedings in a lush hotel in the Swiss city of Montreux.

    It was the first time in 20 years such a hearing was held in public, but it was marred by translation difficulties as Sun gave his hour-long evidence.

    "If you want him to answer the question, the translation must be correct," the swimmer's frustrated counsel Ian Meakin told the gathering.

    Despite having been cleared with a warning from swimming's governing body FINA in January, the World Anti-Doping Agency wants the swimmer banned for up to eight years for an alleged doping violation.

    Vial 'smashed during testing'

    The allegations relate to the night of September the 4th last year when three anti-doping officials arrived at Sun's home in China to conduct routine drug testing.

    The evening ended with a vial of the swimmer's blood allegedly being destroyed with a hammer by a security guard, as Sun watched on, using his mobile phone as a flashlight.

    The drug test was never completed and the blood and urine samples never tested.

    Sun told the hearing he became suspicious when one of the anti-doping team members began taking photos of him on his mobile phone, which he told the hearing was unprofessional.

    Mr Meakin argued the testing team then failed to present the required identification outlined in WADA guidelines, telling the session the observer sent to watch Sun provide his urine sample only produced his national Chinese ID card and the nurse her qualification certificate — but nothing to link them to the testing agency.

    "The officials were not even capable of proving their identity, how could I allow them to take my sample?" Sun questioned during the proceedings.

    "One question, if during the night there was someone, a policeman, came to your house and telling you, 'I'm the policeman but I don't have my identification', how would you react? How would you believe?" Sun asked the hearing.

    But Brent Rychener, counsel for WADA, questioned the validity of the testimony given the number of times Sun had been drug tested during his career.

    "You've given approximately 200 samples, are you saying today that after all the times you have been tested that you are not aware of the legal consequences for refusing to provide a sample?" he asked.

    Richard Young, another counsel for WADA, told the hearing collection agency the International Doping Test Management (IDTM) had collected 19,000 doping tests using the same documentation and had no complaints.

    Tudo Popa, the testing coordinator from IDTM, told the proceeding the correct procedures were followed.

    "We did hundreds of tests with the same principal," he said.

    "So, from my opinion we had all the documents required according to instructions."

    In his closing statement, Sun was scathing of the doping allegation in the Australian media, saying confidential information from the initial FINA report had been leaked and he felt there was a "black power" in operation behind the media coverage.

    "Some Australian media disclosed some very detailed information from this confidential recent decision made by FINA doping panel. I feel there was a black power in operation behind all this media coverage," he said.

    Ban could end swimmer's career

    If the CAS rules in WADA's favour, Sun faces between a two- and eight-year ban, meaning he would miss the Tokyo Olympics next year, and that the 27-year-old's career would likely be over.

    The sentence could be on the harsher side given it would be Sun's second offence.

    He was also banned in 2014 for three months for testing positive for what was then a prohibited substance.

    The swimmer's coach, Australian Denis Cotterell, watched on as eleven hours of proceedings unfolded and is confident Sun will be vindicated.

    "He's really had to suffer be subject to a lot of vilification," Mr Cotterell told the ABC outside the hearing.

    "With the facts coming out the truth will be revealed and I'm confident that he was justified despite the dramatic circumstances of not letting that blood go."

    Sun 'will struggle to clear name'

    If the arbitrator finds in Sun's favour, he can continue to swim but could find it hard to shake the drug cheat tag.

    "I think he will struggle to clear his name," Daniel Reid from the Institute for Sport Business at the Loughborough University told the ABC.

    "There is a strong media narrative now around anti-doping in sport, we like having heroes and villains and it plays well for the media narrative to have the clean versus the doper."

    The court's panel won't deliver its findings for many weeks, possibly in the new year.

    "I don't want to even contemplate it," Mr Cotterell said of a potential ban.

    "I would hope in the future no other athlete would be so disrespected."

    © 2019 ABC Australian Broadcasting Corporation. All rights reserved

     Other Swimming News
     29 Nov: A west Auckland beach that's been off limits for swimming and other water activities for three years can be used again
     28 Nov: A popular Wanaka bay is out of bounds to swimmers - following a wastewater spill
     20 Nov: Doping control assistant involved in Sun Yang drug test says he's a builder who was helping old classmate
     15 Nov: Chinese swimmer Sun Yang fronts Court of Arbitration for Sport over smashed blood vial
     15 Nov: Why Chinese swimmer Sun Yang's doping case is a watershed moment for world sport
     03 Nov: A man's died while swimming in the Riwaka River, in the Tasman District
     25 Oct: A swimming alert has been issued for Auckland's St Mary's Bay, as Watercare monitors the discharge from the Sky City fire
     Top Stories

    New Zealand Rugby would make some changes to the All Blacks head coach selection process if they were to run it again More...

    Some rental agencies are absorbing the loss of business - caused by flooding across the South Island More...

     Today's News

    Kate Hudson’s son “doesn’t care” about getting his driver’s license 8:40

    John Bradley developed a stammer during his time on 'Game of Thrones' 8:10

    New Zealand Rugby would make some changes to the All Blacks head coach selection process if they were to run it again 8:07

    UK election is the continuation — not the end — of this toxic chapter of British politics and history 7:57

    Law and Order:
    An assurance from police that they're doing all they can to find the man involved in a Wellington park stabbing 7:57

    Cracks will emerge, but not to the extent they did a year ago 7:47

    Millie Bobby Brown and Billie Eilish have been honoured at PETA’s 2019 Libby Awards 7:40

    Some rental agencies are absorbing the loss of business - caused by flooding across the South Island 7:37

    New Zealand Rugby would make some changes to the head coach selection process if they were to run it again 7:27

    Rugby League:
    The end appears nigh for Craig Bellamy who admits he does not expect to continue on as an NRL coach after his Melbourne contract expires in two years 7:17

     News Search

    Power Search

    © 2019 New Zealand City Ltd