News | International
28 Feb 2020 14:34
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > International

    Troubled 737 MAX Boeing airplane had at least 13 other safety incidents, ex-employee says

    A former senior Boeing manager reveals he urged management to temporarily shut down the 737 MAX factory in the United States months before the first fatal crash.

    A former senior manager at Boeing, who urged the company to shut down the 737 MAX factory, has revealed the fleet experienced at least 13 other safety incidents in the aircraft's short lifespan.

    Lion Air flight 610 plunged into the ocean off Indonesia in October 2018. Five months later, in March 2019, Ethiopian flight 302 met the same fate.

    In total, 346 people lost their lives.

    It is the worst crisis the aviation juggernaut has dealt with in its century-long history — restoring confidence in its brand while trying to stem the cashflow losses, which have surpassed $US28 billion ($41.6 billion).

    "Something happened in the translation from, 'let's build a high-quality, safe product' to 'let's get it out done on time,'" former Boeing senior manager Ed Pierson told the ABC.

    Ex-Boeing manager recommend factory be shut down after seeing 'chaos'

    Ed Pierson joined Boeing in 2008 after retiring from the Navy as a Captain following three decades of service.

    He was put on the MAX program in 2015. By then, the plant was already under pressure.

    The aircraft maker's top rival, Airbus, had a head start on its new class of plane designed to cost less to run by using less fuel. Boeing was playing catch-up.

    "A lot has been said about the pressure on engineers to get the plane designed and test pilots to get the plane tested," Mr Pierson said.

    "I can tell you with 100 per cent confidence that there was equal if not greater pressure being put on production workers."

    By mid-2018, Mr Pierson said the factory was in a state of "chaos," which compelled him to raise his concerns with senior management.

    "Frankly, right now all my internal alarm bells are going off," Mr Pierson said in an email to Scott Campbell, the general manager of the 737 MAX program.

    "For the first time in my life, I'm sorry to say that I'm hesitant about putting my family on a Boeing airplane."

    Concerned that workers were fatigued, making an unusually high number of mistakes and performing jobs they were not trained for, Mr Pierson made a bold suggestion and urged management to temporarily shut down the factory.

    But his pleas were rejected.

    "My first thought was just because we're a profit-making organisation doesn't give us the right to take chances like that with people's lives," he said.

    "In the military we value life. Sometimes you take risk because that's the mission; but that's a conscious decision.

    "When you take unnecessary risk, that's unacceptable."

    A few months later, he retired from the company. Then in October, he watched in horror as news of the first fatal crash broke.

    "I didn't know it at the time but when I was communicating with the general manager about my concerns, the Lion airplane was in the production system," he said.

    MAX 737 deficiencies went beyond software issues: Pierson

    The two fatal crashes were caused at least in part by the plane's anti-stall system, MCAS, which automatically pushed the plane's nose down, leaving pilots unable to regain control.

    Given the problem occurred in both fatal crashes, authorities and Boeing have focused their attention on fixing the software issue.

    But Mr Pierson remains concerned production problems at the plant in the lead up to the tragedies may also have inadvertently embedded safety defects in subsequent planes.

    Unable to sleep at night, Mr Pierson escalated his concerns to the highest levels of Boeing, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and the National Transport Safety Board (NTSB).

    "I just kept thinking of the families," he said.

    "My dad was a homicide detective and I remember as a kid, he told me how important it was to get information to investigators and for investigators to keep an open mind, so that was my intent," he said.

    But he was stonewalled by both Boeing and the safety authorities, which motivated him to do his own digging.

    He discovered there had been 13 other safety incidents reported on 737 MAX jets between May 2018 and the following March, when the fleet was grounded.

    "We're talking about 380 or so airplanes, 13 incidents, two fatal crashes on top of that," he said.

    "That represents 4 per cent of 387, so basically one in 25 airplanes had already had a safety incident in its short lifespan.

    "I don't know about you, but I certainly don't want my family on a flight when they lose an engine or they do an emergency landing."

    In a statement, the FAA said it "reviewed all available data" thoroughly and found no "incidents related to the MCAS software" but declined to comment further.

    Mr Pierson gave evidence to a congressional committee investigating the fatal crashes and outlined the information he had managed to gather.

    After initially dismissing his concerns, the FAA has now asked him to participate in an interview.

    Boeing said it took Mr Pierson's concerns "seriously" and took "appropriate steps to assess them", adding none of the authorities investigating the fatal crashes found production conditions had contributed to the accidents.

    When specifically asked about the additional safety problems, Boeing said it "thoroughly reviews incidents in coordination with regulatory authorities".

    Boeing's mistakes are economically 'devastating' to suppliers

    The crisis is sending shockwaves through the company's global supply chain with those in Washington state most acutely affected.

    On the outskirts of Seattle, Larry and Rosemary Brester have made specialised parts for Boeing for more than four decades.

    "For us, it's devastating as a small company because we rely on them and their tier 1 and tier 2 suppliers to provide us with work," Ms Brester said.

    "We're devastated not just for us, but for the entire ecosystem that supplies parts to the Boeing company."

    The Bresters, like thousands of other business owners, have heavily relied on the planes for business.

    "We get auction papers in the mail from local companies that are either going bankrupt or they're just closing the doors. They don't see that light at the end of the tunnel," Mr Brester said.

    The husband and wife team run the six-person operation from a shed at the back of their property.

    Every square inch of the factory floor is occupied with machinery, most of it decades old but maintained in perfect working order.

    A large sign hanging on the wall reads "legacies can be built in your garage," displaying the couple's pride of running of their own successful business for almost half a century.

    Both admit that Boeing, the company they have been so proud to work for, has lost its way.

    "Trying to push and increase the production rates, you can only do so much with so many people," Mr Brester said.

    "Mistakes start happening and that's not a good thing, and it's all based on wanting to be in competition with Airbus.

    "To me that's not a good thing; the quality falls off."

    Washington state's rich history of aviation covers the walls — from model planes to photographs featuring the pair with aerospace greats like Buzz Aldrin.

    "It's not just Washington state, Boeing has a presence in every state in the United States — and globally — so it's going to affect the global economy as well," Ms Brester said.

    Economists are already predicting the shutdown could shave half a per cent off America's gross domestic product (GDP).

    Australia will not be immune. It is home to Boeing's largest manufacturing operation outside of the states, which too makes parts for the MAX.

    But the financial pain is not limited to those caught up in Boeing's supply chain.

    Across the road from Boeing's main storage airfield in Seattle sits an old American diner, Randy's Restaurant.

    It has been there so long, it is now part of the furniture.

    "They've been our mainstay for many, many, many years and we're hoping that will continue," Lucia Roadenizer said.

    She and her husband Richard stumbled across the diner some 40 years ago and have run the business since, embracing the state's affiliation with aviation.

    "We try to stay positive and say, 'OK, we're going to get through this,'" she said.

    "We have so far."

    The FAA told the ABC that the 737 MAX series planes would remain grounded as long as needed, but Boeing has already told shareholders it is pinning hopes on a mid-year return to the sky.

    © 2020 ABC Australian Broadcasting Corporation. All rights reserved

     Other International News
     28 Feb: Amazon's new show Hunters has Al Pacino leading a squad of Nazi-fighting vigilantes — but how accurate is it?
     28 Feb: Olympic champion Mo Farah faces renewed doping suspicions following British TV investigation
     28 Feb: A 'mini-moon' has been orbiting the Earth for three years — but astronomers say it will not be around forever
     28 Feb: How your brain disentangles words and melody from a single line of song
     28 Feb: A man has been arrested after Manchester City manager Pep Guardiola's emails were allegedly hacked
     27 Feb: China's Chang'e-4 provides first detailed images of what lies beneath the far side of the Moon
     27 Feb: Our stiff feet have evolved for walking and running, and a large part of that could be thanks to our transverse arch
     Top Stories

    The Crusaders will avoid a trip to Tokyo this Super Rugby season with SANZAAR announcing changes to the draw to allay coronavirus fears in Tokyo More...

    Port of Tauranga has reduced its full-year profit guidance as coronavirus continues to cause trade uncertainty More...

     Today's News

    JoJo felt "free" after being released by her record label 14:29

    Law and Order:
    A year on from a triple fatality at Matata, WorkSafe has laid charges against Higgins Construction 14:07

    Eva Mendes wants to play a Disney villain 13:59

    Veteran Kiwi David Smail has put himself in a position to contend at the New Zealand Open 13:47

    Bebe Rexha doesn't want to be defined by her bipolar disorder diagnosis 13:29

    Law and Order:
    A guilty plea to a murder 24-years ago - has drawn gasps from friends and family of Christchurch woman Angela Blackmoore 13:27

    Law and Order:
    Twenty four years later ... a man has pleaded guilty to beating a young Christchurch mum to death 13:17

    Jacinda Ardern's due to try make moves on Australia's forced deportation of New Zealanders 13:17

    The Crusaders will avoid a trip to Tokyo this Super Rugby season with SANZAAR announcing changes to the draw to allay coronavirus fears in Tokyo 13:07

    Mark Wahlberg's 10-year-old daughter is easily embarrassed by her movie star dad 12:59

     News Search

    Power Search

    © 2020 New Zealand City Ltd