News | National
18 Jun 2024 4:35
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > National

    Top economists give budget modest rating and doubt inflation will fall as planned

    Only one-third of the top economists surveyed give Jim Chalmers’ third budget an A or a B, down from two-thirds in 2023. Many say it left big issues unaddressed.

    Peter Martin, Visiting Fellow, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University
    The Conversation


    Asked to grade Treasurer Jim Chalmers’ third budget on his own criteria of delivering on “inflation in the near term and then growth in the medium term”, most of the 49 leading economists surveyed by the Economic Society of Australia and The Conversation have failed to give it top marks.

    On a grading scale of A to F, 17 of the 49 economists – about one-third – give the budget an A or a B. Two have declined to offer a grade.

    The result is a sharp comedown from Chalmers’ second budget in 2023. Two-thirds of the economists surveyed conferred an A or a B on that budget.

    The economists chosen to take part in the post-budget Economic Society surveys are recognised by their peers as leaders in fields including macroeconomics, economic modelling, housing and budget policy.

    Among them are a former head of the Department of Finance, a former Reserve Bank board member and former Treasury, International Monetary Fund and Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development officials.

    Thirteen of those surveyed – more than a quarter – give the budget a low mark of D or an E. None have given it the lowest possible mark of F.



    Asked whether the budget was likely to achieve its aim of getting inflation back within the Reserve Bank’s 2-3% target band by the end of this year, and back to 2.75% by mid next year, 17 thought it would not. Only ten thought it would.

    A greater number – 21 – were not sure.



    In his budget speech, Chalmers predicted inflation would come back to the Reserve Bank’s target band sooner than the 2025 expected by the Reserve Bank itself, “perhaps even by the end of this year”.

    The budget papers forecast an inflation rate of 2.75% by mid-2025, well within the target band and a half a percentage point lower than the bank’s forecast.

    The papers say two measures in the budget, not known to the Reserve Bank when it produced its forecasts in early May, explain why the budget forecast is half a percentage point lower.

    They are an extra year of energy bill relief of $300 per household and $325 for eligible small businesses and a further 10% increase in the maximum rate of Commonwealth Rent Assistance.



    If the lower budget forecast is correct, and if the Reserve Bank sticks to the letter of its agreement with the treasurer that requires it to aim for consumer price inflation between 2% and 3%, the bank is likely to cut interest rates late this year or early next year as inflation approaches its target zone.

    But economists including Flavio Menezes from The University of Queensland say while the budget measures might “mechanically” suppress measured inflation, they are:

    unlikely to alleviate underlying inflationary pressures and may even exacerbate them; for households not experiencing financial strain, lower energy bills could simply lead to increased spending in other areas.

    Former Reserve Bank board member Warwick Mckibbin says the bank is likely to “see through” (ignore) the largely temporary mechanical price reductions and “raise interest rates to where they should be”.

    Others surveyed, a minority, argue the economy is too weak for the extra spending in the budget to boost inflation through consumer spending. Former Finance Department Secretary Michael Keating says any stimulus is “likely to be swamped by the economic slowing well under way”.

    Independent economist Saul Eslake said the subsidies for energy and rent would inject only $3 billion into the economy in 2024-25. This meant any boost they would give to underlying inflation would be hardly “material”.

    Tax cuts matter more than energy rebates

    More important for boosting the economy would be previously budgeted Stage 3 tax cuts. These are set to inject $23.3 billion per year from June, climbing to $107.2 billion over four years.

    Eslake said the decision to reskew the tax cuts toward middle and lower earners had saved the government from the need to direct extra specific support to these people. Politically, the government could not have got away with doing nothing.

    But Eslake was appalled to discover that the cost of the single biggest spending item in the budget, the untied grants to the states, had blown out even more than expected. The special top-up for Western Australia is now set to cost $53 billion over 11 years instead of the $8.9 billion over eight years expected in 2018.

    How the national government could justify gifting $53 billion to the government of Australia’s richest state was beyond his comprehension.

    Big issues unaddressed

    A repeated theme among the economists was that the budget did very little to boost productivity or address persistent problems.

    Several described it as an election budget, others a budget driven by polling.

    Macquarie University’s Lisa Magnani said the lack of attention to home prices, the funding of public schools and the poor performance of Australian firms was concerning, given Chalmers’ claim it was a budget for “decades to come”.

    Former Department of Foreign Affairs chief economist Jenny Gordon said the budget had failed to tackle the distortions in the housing market and the financial sustainability of needed services including health care, aged care and childcare.

    Australian National University economist Frank Jotzo said crunch time for tax reform was coming, given the large baked-in increases in spending on defence, health and disability insurance and Australia’s over-reliance on income tax and company tax.

    McKibbin said Australia’s main economic problems were its lack of productivity growth, the big changes needed to bring about the energy transition, the surge in artificial intelligence, the risk of much lower export prices and global geopolitical uncertainty.

    The government should have tried to build a bipartisan consensus about how to fix these.

    Private investors were hanging back knowing that whatever the government did could be reversed at the next election.

    Although many of those surveyed welcomed the Future Made in Australia Act, some criticised its approach of “picking winners” and “wasting precious resources” by putting money into activities such as the manufacture of solar panels, which could be done more cheaply elsewhere.

    Bigger government

    Former Industry Department chief economist Mark Cully said it was in some ways one of the most consequential budgets in years.

    It locked in a clear shift towards higher spending and revenue, which, at around 26% of GDP, was higher than any other time Australia had been near full employment.

    Future Made in Australia was the most marked intervention by a government in shaping the future direction of the economy for decades.


    Individual responses. Click to open:


    The Conversation

    Peter Martin is the economics editor of The Conversation and serves on the central council of the Economic Society of Australia.

    This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license.
    © 2024 TheConversation, NZCity

     Other National News
     17 Jun: All passengers on board a flight which made an emergency landing in Invercargill have disembarked
     17 Jun: A Virgin Australia flight's been diverted to Invercargill after experiencing an issue shortly after taking off from Queenstown Airport
     17 Jun: Police using Auckland's Eagle helicopter to help the search for on the run Marokopa man, Tom Phillips, have made the most of the trip
     17 Jun: A spike in cases forced Wellington Hospital to designate a separate ward for Covid patients early this month
     17 Jun: One lane has reopened on State Highway One south of Taihape, after a truck rolled early this morning
     17 Jun: Waikato Bay of Plenty Magic midcourter Ali Wilshier's ANZ Premiership netball season is over
     17 Jun: A man's appearing appear in Auckland District Court today - charged with 27 counts of fraud, accused of weeks of scams on Facebook Marketplace
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    Forward Hyrum Harris is a late scratching from the Tall Blacks squad ahead of next month's FIBA Olympic qualifying tournament More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    The 2024 tax season is well under way -- with 2.7 million New Zealanders already receiving assessments More...



     Today's News

    Politics:
    Birmingham, Britain's second-largest city, is being forced to dim lights and cut sanitation services due to bankruptcy 23:07

    Rugby League:
    Warriors wing Dallin Watene-Zelezniak has taken the early guilty plea on his dangerous high tackle from the Melbourne loss and will miss Saturday evening's NRL match against the Titans on the Gold Coast 21:57

    Entertainment:
    Tony Bennett's children are fighting over his estate less than a year after the crooner's death 21:46

    International:
    Fresh attacks against Rohingya in Myanmar, UN decries beheadings, violence 21:27

    Living & Travel:
    All passengers on board a flight which made an emergency landing in Invercargill have disembarked 21:17

    Entertainment:
    Kourtney Kardashian is moving in with her husband Travis Barker two years after they tied the knot 21:16

    Entertainment:
    Andrew Scott battled a speech impediment as a child 20:46

    Entertainment:
    Katie Price claims her home has been targeted by a burglar who stole a "car load" of her possessions 20:16

    Entertainment:
    John Legend aspires to be a father like his dad Ronald Stephens 19:46

    Entertainment:
    Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco have reunited after being kept apart by her work 19:16


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2024 New Zealand City Ltd