News | National
10 Oct 2024 10:14
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > National

    The Foodstuffs merger is dead – but that still won’t fix NZ’s over-concentrated supermarket sector

    New Zealanders have less choice over their grocery shop than consumers in most developed countries. Breaking up the existing supermarket conglomerates would be a next logical step.

    Lisa M. Katerina Asher, Retail Expert, PhD Candidate & Sessional Academic, University of Sydney, Drew Franklin, Senior Lecturer in Marketing, University of Auckland, Waipapa Taumata Rau
    The Conversation


    Two of the dominant players in New Zealand’s supermarket sector – Foodstuffs North Island and Foodstuffs South Island – have failed in their quest to officially join forces.

    In a decision announced yesterday, the Commerce Commission declined to green-light the merger between the two cooperatives. The watchdog said it was not satisfied the move wouldn’t result in reducing competition in the New Zealand grocery sector.

    But it needs to go further.

    Instead of adjudicating on a merger, the commission should be given the power to break up the two Foodstuffs entities themselves. Local competitors, such as the Warehouse or others, should also be encouraged to ensure shoppers get the best deals.

    Seeking a dominant union

    In their December 2023 application, the two cooperatives said they would be more efficient and have greater buying power as one entity.

    Foodstuffs North Island and Foodstuffs South Island argued the levels of competition in the supermarket sector would not decrease with the merger.

    The two entities admitted to already sharing information and not meaningfully competing against each other in the same regions. This is set to continue with the failure of their application to merge.

    Multiple submissions to the Commerce Commission, such as those from academics Tim Hazeldine and Robert Hamlin, claimed Foodstuffs’ unwillingness to compete with each other demonstrated a worrying precedent in New Zealand.

    The Grocery Action Group also claimed the two Foodstuffs’ entities breached consumer trust because one is an actual cooperative (Foodstuffs South Island), while 93% of Foodstuffs North Island’s shares are owned by four people who do not own physical stores.

    This is an issue, as they continue to claim they are both owner-operated cooperatives, when only Foodstuffs South Island legally is.

    Further submissions by industry bodies representing suppliers and Consumer NZ included concerns a merger would reduce competition.

    The concentrated supermarket sector

    International research has long found competition is good for prices.

    But New Zealanders have less choice of where to do their grocery shop compared with other developed nations. The sector is dominated by the Foodstuffs entities – which include Pak'nSave, New World and Four Square – and Australian-based Woolworths (which also owns Fresh Choice).

    In New Zealand there is one supermarket for every 12,871 people, while in Germany there is one for every 3,009, and one for every 5,563 in Ireland, a similar-sized island nation. New Zealand supermarkets generate the highest annual revenue per store among developed markets at US$27.9 million, versus $19.56m in the United States, $7.7m in Germany and $17.02m in Ireland.

    Foodstuffs North Island’s current market share is just over 40%. Merging with Foodstuffs South Island would have increased the single entity’s national market share to 55%.

    The Grocery Commission, set up in response to the Commerce Commission’s study of the supermarket sector, recently released its first annual report.

    It found there was no meaningful competition in the sector and more competition was needed. It further highlighted that profit margins had increased since the 2022 market study.

    Challenging mergers

    New Zealand is not the only country where regulators are pushing back against supermarket mergers.

    In August, the US Federal Trade Commission brought an emergency injunction blocking the merger between supermarket giants Albertsons and Kroger.

    The US$24.6 billion proposal would have been the largest supermarket merger in US history, with a combined market share of just under 20%.

    The court case, which is yet to be decided, included revelations of price gouging by Kroger. Albertsons is Kroger’s primary price competitor, meaning absorbing them would remove competition and the need to compete on price.

    The Albertsons-Kroger merger would substantially lessen competition and trigger price increases.

    In the United Kingdom, the Competition and Markets Authority blocked a 2019 merger between Asda and Sainsbury’s. At the time, the authority said shoppers would be worse off if the two supermarkets, with a combined market share of 31%, merged.

    Time to break up the sector further

    As we see in foreign markets, the push for market power to return higher profits is likely to continue. But when those businesses provide basic necessities, such as food, more competition is required, not less.

    The proposed merger process has provided greater insight into the structure of Foodstuffs North Island and Foodstuffs South Island – including where the two organisations already work together.

    As argued in some of the submissions to the Commerce Commission, the next logical step would be to separate Pak'nSave from the other Foodstuffs brands and encourage nationwide competition. If broken up, the new companies should be renamed to create separation from the current brands.

    The Commerce Commission’s decision on the proposed Foodstuffs merger reinforces concerns about competition in New Zealand’s supermarket sector, as does the report from the Grocery Commission and the earlier grocery sector study.

    If competition creates better prices for consumers, then splitting up New Zealand’s concentrated supermarket sector is the logical next step.

    The Conversation

    Lisa Asher made four submissions against the merger to the Commerce Commission in her capacity as an academic.

    Drew Franklin does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

    This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license.
    © 2024 TheConversation, NZCity

     Other National News
     10 Oct: Sex machina: in the wild west world of human-AI relationships, the lonely and vulnerable are most at risk
     10 Oct: Australian forward Stefan Colakovski has been signed by the Wellington Phoenix, 10 days from the start of the A-League football season
     10 Oct: An air conditioning fault has caused an Air New Zealand flight from Christchurch to Auckland to make an emergency landing at Nelson Airport
     09 Oct: Police have arrested a 39-year old man after he allegedly rammed two police cars and assaulted officers in Hamilton
     09 Oct: The father who's two teenage children died in a dangerous driving crash, has escaped a prison sentence
     09 Oct: A geomagnetic storm has hit Earth – a space scientist explains what causes them
     09 Oct: Christchurch police are visiting properties, including businesses, as part of the ongoing Mount Pleasant homicide inquiry
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    TJ Perenara will have a farewell from the capital in Wellington colours More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    Expect another cut to the Official Cash Rate before Christmas More...



     Today's News

    National:
    Sex machina: in the wild west world of human-AI relationships, the lonely and vulnerable are most at risk 10:07

    Soccer:
    Australian forward Stefan Colakovski has been signed by the Wellington Phoenix, 10 days from the start of the A-League football season 10:07

    Entertainment:
    Eric Idle "shouldn't be alive" 9:54

    International:
    Joe Biden and Benjamin Netanyahu talk for first time in weeks — has their relationship soured as Middle East war escalates? 9:37

    Health & Safety:
    Concern, New Zealand's on the precipice of a whooping cough outbreak, as monthly case numbers spike 9:27

    Entertainment:
    Keith Urban wants to help his teenage daughter "keep balance" after she made her modelling debut 9:24

    Entertainment:
    Joe Locke wants to get "hate-tweeted" by Donald Trump 8:54

    Rugby:
    TJ Perenara will have a farewell from the capital in Wellington colours 8:37

    Entertainment:
    Marisa Abela feared her career was over after she had thyroid cancer surgery 8:24

    Motoring:
    Former Supercars driver Greg Murphy has endorsed next season's new format 8:17


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2024 New Zealand City Ltd