News | National
12 Dec 2024 19:33
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > National

    Land of opportunity or bicultural nation? Twin visions of national identity face off over the Treaty principles

    The Treaty Principles Bill pits two ideas about national identity against each other – egalitarianism and biculturalism. But are they really mutually exclusive?

    Olli Hellmann, Associate Professor of Political Science, University of Waikato
    The Conversation


    The controversial Principles of the Treaty of Waitangi Bill is being presented by its architect, ACT Party leader David Seymour, primarily as a matter of lawmaking – a clarification through legislation.

    The bill seeks to redefine the principles of the Treaty of Waitangi – established by decades of case law and jurisprudence – and instead enshrine new principles in law.

    But the bill goes deeper than that, and touches on delicate but fundamental questions of what it means to be a New Zealander.

    In the heated debate since the bill’s introduction, two ideas of national identity come head to head. And the implications for social cohesion and the quality of democratic debate are serious.

    Equal and democratic vs bicultural nation

    For the first few decades of colonial settlement, New Zealand’s identity was contained within an imperial one. The colony aspired to be a “Britain of the South”. It was only from the 1950s that European New Zealanders began to develop a distinct identity.

    Pakeha national identity was constructed around ideas of political and economic egalitarianism. These emphasised hard work and social mobility, and portrayed New Zealand as a “land of opportunity” or a “classless society”.

    The ‘land of opportunity’ myth is rooted in popular views of emigration in the 1800s. Alexander Turnbull Library

    But these notions of the “equal and democratic” nation excluded Maori and perpetuated a monocultural vision of New Zealand. In fact, for Maori, the process of colonisation was anything but an egalitarian experience.

    Not only did the loss of ancestral land – through forceful confiscations and the introduction of private property laws – fuel poverty and economic inequality, but Maori were also denied the political rights promised to them in the Maori text of te Tiriti o Waitangi.

    Grievances over cultural assimilation, historical injustices and political self-determination galvanised a growing Maori protest movement. In the 1970s and 1980s, governments responded by creating the Waitangi Tribunal and by fostering a bicultural understanding of New Zealand national identity.

    Since then, this shift towards greater biculturalism has happened on several levels: weaving Maori culture and language into the fabric of the nation, educating the public about the Waitangi Tribunal’s role in addressing historical wrongs, and promoting the Treaty as the main symbol of Aotearoa-New Zealandness.

    Recently published survey data show the bicultural understanding of national identity has taken root among younger generations: 85.4% of those aged 18 to 34 agree that “Maori culture helps to define New Zealand in positive ways”, compared to 63.1% of people aged 65 and over.

    Similarly, the younger generation is more likely (59.4%) to accept that “we as a nation have a responsibility to see that due settlement is offered to Maori in compensation for past injustices” than the older generation (37.8%).

    Support for biculturalism is particularly strong among young New Zealanders. Getty Images

    The threat of culture wars

    The Treaty Principles Bill magnifies the differences between these two different ideas of New Zealand national identity.

    Seymour says “the Treaty must be consistent with a liberal democracy and give equal rights to each person that has to live in this country”. As such, the bill aligns with the “equal and democratic” image of New Zealandness.

    What is more, by implicitly framing the Treaty as a governance agreement, rather than a partnership between Maori and the Crown, the bill challenges the very interpretation of the Treaty underpinning the bicultural vision of the nation.

    New Zealand has previously experienced the kind of divisions so-called culture wars thrive on, for example in public debates about the use of te reo Maori in public life or officially renaming the country Aotearoa.

    But the Treaty Principles Bill threatens to inflame a battle over national identity, deepening those divisions and reinforcing them through overlapping generational differences.

    As the sociologist James Davison has argued, American-style culture wars, which have spread to other countries, have the potential to “break democracy”.

    Not only do they exacerbate a sense of “us versus them,” but they also narrow political discourse. The focus shifts towards emotionally laden, symbolic disagreements, away from real social and economic issues.

    Great divides: US culture wars threaten to ‘break democracy’. Getty Images

    Bicultural egalitarianism

    At one level, avoiding a culture war escalation requires holding accountable those politicians who engage in divisive rhetoric. But it might also involve reducing tensions by emphasising shared values across the two interpretations of New Zealand identity.

    One possible way to do this is to stretch the idea of egalitarianism – which is central to the image of the “equal and democratic” nation – beyond its usual meaning of equality of opportunity.

    If we expand its definition to include equality of outcome, the bicultural commitment to provide financial reparations as a means to improve the economic situation of Maori – which continues to be marked by colonial legacies – fits the “equal and democratic” vision.

    We could also broaden egalitarianism to mean “epistemic” equality, which stresses the importance of extending equal value to diverse ways of seeing and knowing about the world.

    This could help develop a more inclusive narrative of national identity that combines notions of egalitarianism with biculturalism – manifested, for example, in bicultural governance arrangements informed by matauranga Maori, a Maori worldview.

    The Conversation

    Olli Hellmann does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

    This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license.
    © 2024 TheConversation, NZCity

     Other National News
     12 Dec: Evacuees near a scrub fire on the outskirts of Christchurch have been given the all clear to return
     12 Dec: Police have arrested a man - accused of aiming a gun at a person in Manurewa yesterday
     12 Dec: Canterbury Rally and Rally Coromandel will return to the New Zealand Championship next year
     12 Dec: Police want to hear from people who may have witnessed concerning behaviour before a Hutt Valley homicide
     12 Dec: Canterbury fire crews have been called to a grass fire in Burnham, south of Christchurch
     12 Dec: A large-scale emergency response has sparked south of Christchurch, as a series of grass fires burn
     12 Dec: Deliberate disinformation campaigns are a public health risk – but NZ has no effective strategy to deal with it
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    An early visit from The Grinch for many All Blacks - with Ford set to end their sponsorship of New Zealand Rugby More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    Changes to tenancy laws have passed their third reading in the House More...



     Today's News

    Entertainment:
    Queen Elizabeth used to wear her Imperial State Crown to bath her kids 19:24

    Business:
    Changes to tenancy laws have passed their third reading in the House 18:57

    Entertainment:
    Olivia Wilde thinks social media is "dangerous" for filmmaking 18:54

    Environment:
    Evacuees near a scrub fire on the outskirts of Christchurch have been given the all clear to return 18:37

    Law and Order:
    Beinash Batool and Urfan Sharif found guilty of daughter Sarah Sharif's murder in UK 18:27

    Entertainment:
    Kerry Katona feared she was "going to die" after crashing her car into a tree 18:24

    Law and Order:
    Police have arrested a man - accused of aiming a gun at a person in Manurewa yesterday 18:07

    Entertainment:
    Amy Adams stopped wearing make-up because it upset her young daughter 17:54

    Politics:
    PNG asylum seekers stripped of government-provided housing and healthcare under new deal 17:37

    Politics:
    Confirmation more jobs will be cut at the Office for Crown Maori relations 17:27


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2024 New Zealand City Ltd