News | National
17 Feb 2025 5:36
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > National

    Trump’s war on migrants could make an enemy of the country he needs most: Mexico

    Trump’s efforts to stop a so-called ‘invasion’ of migrants could imperil relations with the US’s biggest trading partner, Mexico.

    Luis Gómez Romero, Senior Lecturer in Human Rights, Constitutional Law and Legal Theory, University of Wollongong
    The Conversation


    On his first day in office, Donald Trump launched his second term with a barrage of executive orders. Unsurprisingly, many could have a major impact on Mexico, which shares a 3,145-kilometre border with the US and more than 200 years of diplomatic and economic ties.

    Yet, this deep interdependence has not stopped Trump from making Mexico a prime target of his divisive political rhetoric.

    He entered the public arena in 2015 by condemning Mexicans as dangerous “rapists” and criminals who were “bringing drugs” into the US. He also vowed to build “a great, great wall” along the border – one he claimed Mexico would pay for – to stop undocumented immigrants.

    During his second presidential campaign, Trump doubled down on his anti-Mexico rhetoric and agenda. He threatened mass deportations of undocumented migrants residing in the US, sweeping tariffs of over 200% on Mexican vehicle imports and sending special forces into Mexico to attack drug cartels.

    Trump’s executive orders are now putting these threats into action. Among the most concerning:

    Though largely symbolic, the order to rename the Gulf of Mexico as the “Gulf of America” further strains bilateral relations.

    Given this focus, Trump’s long shadow will loom over Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum’s own time in office. She will have to navigate his hostility while tackling domestic challenges, including a controversial judicial reform plan and relentless violence.

    She has responded to Trump’s actions with measured remarks so far:

    We have to avoid confrontations […] At the same time, we have to behave as equals, never subordinate. Defend our sovereignty, our independence and defend Mexicans.

    A heavily securitised border

    Trump’s declaration of a national emergency allows him to deploy the military to the border and continue building a border wall without Congressional approval. He could also enact measures to expand detention facilities, transportation (including aircraft) and other logistical support for law enforcement.

    Illegal border crossings actually declined dramatically in 2024. This was, in part, due to steps Mexican authorities have taken to stop migrants attempting to reach the US.

    Mexican authorities reported detaining over 475,000 migrants in the last quarter of 2024 — nearly 68% more than in the same period a year earlier.

    Despite these efforts – which have drawn criticism for human rights groups – Trump has labelled migrant crossings an “invasion.”

    This belligerent rhetoric is dangerous, as an invasion implies military aggression.

    Indeed, Trump’s executive order authorises the deployment of US troops on the border, though details are thin. He could seek the assistance of the National Guard, a state-based military force made up of civilian soldiers. US law, however, prohibits the use of regular military forces on domestic soil.

    In any case, Mexico serves as a stark example of why using the military for law enforcement is unwise. More than a decade of data shows that military involvement fails to encourage lawful behaviour and instead fuels corruption and violence.

    Prospects for unilateral military action

    Trump has also initiated the process to designate Mexican drug cartels as terrorist organisations – an action Mexico has long opposed.

    Combined with his directive for the US secretary of defence to halt “the unimpeded flow of opiates” across the Mexico-US border, this could ultimately lead to US military action against organised crime in Mexico.

    Sheinbaum responded by reaffirming Mexico’s sovereignty. She noted that while the US can act within its territory, Mexico remains an independent state.

    In a letter to Trump last November, she highlighted that in 2024, Mexican law enforcement seized 10,340 weapons and arrested 15,640 people for drug-related violence. She also correctly pointed out that Mexico neither produces weapons, nor has a national public health crisis linked to synthetic drugs like fentanyl.

    Yet, she lamented that Mexicans “bear the brunt of the deaths caused by crime” driven by the demand for drugs north of the border.

    Any unilateral US military action inside Mexico could seriously imperil relations between the two neighbours.

    The last time the US seriously considered military action against Mexico was in 1927, when Mexico enacted petroleum and land laws that affected American interests. Since then, the relationship has had its ups and downs, but has never involved military force.

    And these kinds of threats could have ripple effects across Latin America. As former Colombian President Ernesto Samper has warned, an intervention in Mexico could spark a “Vietnam syndrome” of anti-American sentiment throughout the region.

    Tariffs will hurt both sides

    In addition, Trump has vowed to impose 25% tariffs on Mexico and Canada starting on February 1.

    Such tariffs, however, could not be implemented without also hurting US industries.

    Mexico overtook China as the US’s top trading partner in 2023, with bilateral trade reaching US$807 billion (A$1.2 trillion). Mexico’s economy relies heavily on trade, with 83% of exports destined for the US.

    In return, Mexico’s direct investments in the US totalled US$33.8 billion (A$54 billion) in 2022 – an impressive 21.5% increase over the previous year.

    The Mexican and US economies are tightly intertwined. If Trump imposes tariffs on Mexican beer, for example, he will also be imposing them on barley from Idaho, Montana and North Dakota that’s used to make the beer.

    Sheinbaum has accurately warned Trump that tariffs are not just unacceptable under the United States–Mexico–Canada Agreement – they will also result in “inflation and job losses” across both the US and Mexico.

    A relationship on the rocks?

    Sheinbaum has advised Mexicans to “keep their heads cool”.

    But as Trump continues to exert pressure on Mexico, it will become increasingly difficult for her to convince the Mexican public of the benefits of maintaining a cooperative relationship with the US.

    The potential deterioration of relations between Mexico and the US could signal a new era in which brute force, paradoxically, will diminish American influence in the international community.

    The Conversation

    Luis Gómez Romero does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

    This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license.
    © 2025 TheConversation, NZCity

     Other National News
     16 Feb: One person has serious injuries after a crash which has closed State Highway 2 at Tutira in Hawke's Bay
     16 Feb: A temporary relief station is now operating for people affected by a fire on the third floor of a multi-storey building in Wellington's Willis Street
     16 Feb: Wellington Phoenix women's coach Paul Temple believes winning tonight's A-League clash against the Glory in Perth is vital for their play-off hopes
     16 Feb: Labour's Leader has labelled anti-LGBTQ protests 'pathetic'
     16 Feb: Taranaki has enjoyed its first successful defence of cricket's Hawke Cup since 1995
     16 Feb: Firefighters are working to clear a block of flats in Wellington's Aro Valley of smoke - after a fire broke out in one of the apartments
     16 Feb: Hawke's Bay Police are hunting the driver of a car who ploughed into a Flaxmere home last night
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    New Zealand Rugby CEO Mark Robinson believes Joe Schmidt won't be lost to Australian rugby when he steps down as head coach at the end of the Rugby Championship More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    Resale conditions are improving in New Zealand's property market More...



     Today's News

    Accident and Emergency:
    A motorcyclist has been critically injured in a crash on State Highway 73, the Arthur's Pass road 21:56

    Motoring:
    For South Island motorists: a crash has closed State Highway 73 between Arthurs Pass and Otira 21:16

    Politics:
    Education Minister Erica Stanford says her associate minister, David Seymour, was overstepping the mark when he announced a crackdown on teacher-only days last year 18:56

    Entertainment:
    Stampede at Indian railway station kills Maha Kumbh festival pilgrims 18:46

    Accident and Emergency:
    One person has serious injuries after a crash which has closed State Highway 2 at Tutira in Hawke's Bay 18:36

    Rugby:
    New Zealand Rugby CEO Mark Robinson believes Joe Schmidt won't be lost to Australian rugby when he steps down as head coach at the end of the Rugby Championship 18:06

    Environment:
    A temporary relief station is now operating for people affected by a fire on the third floor of a multi-storey building in Wellington's Willis Street 17:46

    Soccer:
    Wellington Phoenix women's coach Paul Temple believes winning tonight's A-League clash against the Glory in Perth is vital for their play-off hopes 17:46

    Rugby League:
    Warriors co-captain James Fisher-Harris believes the All-Stars teams should always be at full strength 17:36

    Cricket:
    Former Black Caps coach Mike Hesson believes the openers are a point of contention in New Zealand's ODI side heading into the Champions Trophy this week 16:56


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2025 New Zealand City Ltd