News | International
4 Oct 2024 22:20
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • News
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > International

    Russia has captured Vuhledar after two years of Ukrainian resistance. How significant is the capture?

    The key front-line Ukrainian town of Vuhledar has spent the last two years fighting tooth and nail to resist repeated attacks from Russia. Now, Moscow's soldiers have taken complete control. What does this mean?

    4 October 2024

    Ukrainian soldiers have spent the last two years fighting tooth and nail in the key front-line town of Vuhledar to resist repeated Russian attack.

    But this week, those troops received an order to pull back from the town in the country's eastern Donetsk region to avoid encirclement by Russian troops and "preserve personnel and military equipment", Ukraine's eastern military command confirmed. 

    The advance of Moscow's forces means that Russian troops are now in complete control of the town — which Russia has long regarded as one of Ukraine's toughest fortified positions to crack.

    The capture is a major boost for the Kremlin and has confirmed Russia's vast superiority in men and material as Ukraine pleads for more weapons from the Western allies that have been supporting it.

    But how significant is it really? Here's what we know. 

    What is Vuhledar? 

    Vuhledar is on strategic high ground in eastern Ukraine that has resisted Russian assaults since Moscow's full-scale invasion in 2022. 

    The town, whose name means 'gift of coal', was built around a mine by the Soviet Union in the mid-1960s. 

    It had a pre-war population of over 14,000, nearly all of whom have fled following Russia's capture which left the town devastated.

    Why did Russia want to take Vuhledar?

    Moscow says the Donetsk region is one of four Ukrainian regions it has annexed since 2022, a claim Kyiv rejects as illegal. 

    Moscow saw taking control of Vuhledar as an important stepping stone to incorporating the entire region into Russia.

    Both sides consider control of the town important due to its position on elevated ground and because it sits at the intersection of the eastern and southern battlefield fronts — giving it added significance when it comes to supplying both sides' forces.

    While Ukrainian forces were in full control of Vuhledar, they were able to use the town as a platform to shell Russian military supply lines in the area.

    The town sits close to a railway line from Crimea, the Black Sea peninsula which Russia annexed from Ukraine in 2014, to Ukraine's industrialised Donbas region which comprises Donetsk and the eastern region of Luhansk, most of which Moscow controls.

    Taking Vuhledar, which Russia portrays as one of the last Ukrainian strongholds in southern Donetsk, opens the way for Russian forces to advance on other areas.

    How did Russia take control? 

    Russian forces trapped Ukrainian soldiers in Vuhledar in what they called a 'mini-cauldron'.

    To translate, they gradually encircled it from all sides and thus making it increasingly difficult for Ukrainian forces to resupply or rotate in and out of the town.

    When such a cauldron closes (something Russian military bloggers say has already happened) there is no way in or out for the defenders — who in this case were bombarded with devastating aerial glide bombs.

    Russian forces had previously launched at least four major attempts to take Vuhledar, but had been repelled with Ukraine's 72nd Separate Mechanised Brigade mounting fierce resistance.

    Neither side discloses losses, but Ukrainian officials said Russian losses sustained during previous failed attempts to take the town had been significant. Moscow says Ukraine also paid a high human price when trying to retain Vuhledar.

    How significant is the capture? 

    This victory is significant for a few reasons.

    Speaking to ABC News Channel, Director of the Ukrainian Studies Foundation Olga Boichak said that it is important to understand that each city captured by Russia "is no more".

    "When we hear the news that another city has fallen to the Russian occupants, we have to understand that this is one more example of Russia's scorched earth policy," she said. 

    "There's really no building intact in Vuhledar anymore and the Ukrainian army has held it heroically for almost two years and had to surrender because they were short on," she said. 

    She said the capture was "really tragic" for Ukraine, both in the immediate perspective and through long-term effects.

    "We have the eastern battlefront, that's the sort of the Donetsk direction, and we also have the southern battlefront which is closer to Zaporizhzhia," she said. 

    "So right now with the falling of Vuhledar, we can pretty much see a united single front which is the eastern and the southern ends really jeopardises the Pokrovsk."

    But when it comes to long-term effects, Ms Boichak says the most important is asking where and when will Putin stop? 

    "I think we are wise enough to know the answer and that answer is, 'no'," she said. 

    ABC/wires

    © 2024 ABC, NZCity


     Other International News
     04 Oct: Peter Dutton calls for Iranian ambassador to be expelled after tweet praising slain Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah
     04 Oct: Home brand products are cheaper at the supermarket. But are they good value?
     04 Oct: Middle East war live: Israel strikes Beirut again as Qantas offers two free flights to evacuate Australians
     04 Oct: US country singer Garth Brooks responds to rape and sexual assault lawsuit
     04 Oct: Deadly bird flu strain H5N1 kills dozens of captive tigers in Vietnam zoos
     04 Oct: Melania Trump suggests support for abortion rights, constrasting with husband Donald Trump
     04 Oct: Four years on, the lessons of the 2020 NRL grand final still drive Penrith ahead of their rematch with Melbourne
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    It's win or go home time - for the whole season - for the desperate Otago men's NPC rugby side tonight More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    Shane Reti's backing Health New Zealand bosses -- despite the agency reporting a deficit of nearly a billion dollars for the past financial year More...



     Today's News

    Rugby:
    It's win or go home time - for the whole season - for the desperate Otago men's NPC rugby side tonight 21:57

    International:
    Peter Dutton calls for Iranian ambassador to be expelled after tweet praising slain Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah 21:47

    Entertainment:
    Morgan Wallen has donated $500,000 to the Hurricane Helene relief effort 21:39

    Rugby:
    The result keeps Otago's playoff hopes alive as they leap to 8th on the table 21:17

    Entertainment:
    Raven-Symone has revealed her father has died 11 months after her brother's death 21:09

    International:
    Home brand products are cheaper at the supermarket. But are they good value? 21:07

    Entertainment:
    Jameela Jamil says her "body is broken forever" by society's beauty standards 20:39

    International:
    Middle East war live: Israel strikes Beirut again as Qantas offers two free flights to evacuate Australians 20:37

    Entertainment:
    Kristin Cavallari's custody arrangement has "changed" 20:09

    Entertainment:
    Elton John has "never felt happiness" like he has now 19:39


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2024 New Zealand City Ltd